The 2 articles from TNP on bullying in school reminded me of my own experience when I first moved to Singapore.
Not being able to speak English and very little Chinese, I too was the target of bullying among my classmates. Fortunately for me, I made some friends who took the same school bus together and I was not alone like many victims reported in the paper. Fortunately for me too, I finally recognised I was being unjustly treated, and fought back.
I surprised myself then when I discovered I was stronger that the bullies. In a one-against-two fight, I knocked both down. That was in lower primary. Nobody from my level ever raised a hand against me after that.
In upper primary, I encountered bullies from those in extended monolingual class (a system scrapped by now). They're older, and bigger.
Whether it is through innate wisdom or sense of self-preservation, I avoided engaging them physically but just stood my ground. And they learned soon enough I had no qualms reporting them to the office.
The first time I did that, the discipline master in the office actually sent me to go up alone to the bully's class to summon him down to the office. Fortunately, I was too inexperienced to recognise what a stupid thing it was for the discipline master to do.
Walking ahead of me, the bully punched his fist to the wall on the way to the office, and there, I witnessed him being caned. Much later, I was told that the bully tried to find out from my classmates how I go home from school, but no one dared to say anything. Ironically, that particular classmate was someone I didn't like, but my friend was telling me to ease up with him. I'm not a perfect guy either. In any case, I never tried to hide my movements so if the bully spied on me, he'd find out eventually.
At that time, my deduction was bullies mentally sized up their potential targets.
There were those who are too timid to resist. They're the easy ones, fun to pick on. They 'play the game'.
There were those who fight back in such a way they descend to the same level as the bullies. These become "bad boys" too in the eyes of the teachers. They 'play the game' too.
Then, there are those who refuse to play the game, like me. And the bullies avoid antagonising us.
Mine was a neighbourhood primary school, straddling between HDB estate and landed private housing estate. Eventually, I see enough of them outside school in the local neighbourhood and they stopped pretending to be aggressive to me.
Can't say we're friends, we're not. But it was a strange feeling when I realised these bullies are just ... acting. I'm not sure if it was a role expected of them being in extended class, or what reason.
I'm glad I stood up for myself. Now, I got to look out my own children growing up and encountering their own bullies.
But the worst bully in my primary school were not those over-aged kids. It was my first form teacher who taught Mandarin.
She was very snideful of new students who for whatever reason, she took a dislike from the start. I was not the latest student to join her class that year. There was another student, and on his first day, she actually said of the student "也不是什么好东西". And he had not done anything wrong.
It was my first time in a strange foreign land. What do I know about what I'm supposed to do when given donation card (don't even know what they were then). I didn't understand the instruction, and didn't understand I'm supposed to bring them back, with some money. And I didn't understand the repeated reminders ... until once she got so fed up she pulled my ears.
And not only did she denied she pulled my ears, she confronted me in front of the whole class about it. My only regret was I was too young to do anything else but keep quiet to her accusations. I did remember tearing in silence.
My primary school days were never fraught with bullyings, despite Poi Ching being a neighbourhood school with some of the rougher elements of Toa Payoh descending on it. By and large, I stood up for myself but I remember an incident in which my attempts to protect a friend from bullies went crazily wrong. Instead of being commended, I ended up being reprimanded by the discipline master for fighting back. What a slimy little bastard that bully was.
ReplyDeleteTeachers can be quite unfair too. I was lucky to be seen as a "good boy".
ReplyDeleteI think the bullying did leave a psychological scar on me though ... I'm inflamed easily even today when I perceive I'm being unfairly treated or wrongly accused ... I get very angry, welling up a sense of indignation, and unable to calm down until things are set right.
Spared not are even stubborn old folks who selfishly barged into MRT trains before allowing passengers to alight first ...
Spared not from my verbal scathings was a senior citizen who came out from the lift smoking a cigarette ...
My wife deplored this aspect of me. Speck in the brother's eye and plank in my own eye ...
She does know me well that I'm blind to some of my own faults.
Well, at least you're honest enough to admit it. :) I have noticed that you do tend to inflame rather easily, which is probably why you hold yourself above those things which would inflame you (on CHF for example).
ReplyDeleteDon't worry lah, we all have our quirks and foibles. If we can't learn to live with them, then how can we survive in this world filled with quirks and foibles? ;)
I faced down a bully once. He threatened the usual "Meet me down at the school field after school if you dare".
ReplyDeleteOne day, I dared.
Did we fight? Nah. I was pissed at the bullying and thought I'd give it a try even if I end up getting the crap beaten out of me. We stood there both in some silly karate stance...
I think no one had ever taken up his challenge before. I think I may have been recklessly nuts to have done it but fortunately it was all a bluff. What would have happened if he had really decided to beat the crap out of me? Or worse, brought a gang to help?
I remember he actually looked a little nervous. He tried to be macho with some comment about not feeling like fighting and respecting my guts etc. etc. but that was all bullshit. He smiled and we both ended up looking sheepishly at each other before walking off.
Most bullies are NATO. And if they aren't...well, orh bee lor...just have to choose your fights wisely. ;)
ReplyDeleteWas it that obvious? :P I know there were a couple of posters I berated before but ...
ReplyDeleteDarn it all ... didn't mean for snowybeagle to become fierybeagle ...
must be cool ... bring back the snow in snowybeagle ...
Precisely what I'm wondering to tell my children ... perhaps 1% chance of it being a serious danger, but it's still a threat.
ReplyDeleteReminds me of what happened in JC once though ...
A guy challenged me to go outside school to fight ...
I counter-challenged him to do it there and then in the school's canteen ...
Only small fries and cowards fight where they can run away easily, I told him.
My best defence I found ever since middle school... be unpredictably quirky. Do strange things, be unfanthomable, do the things people don't think of doing. No one knows what to expect of you. Increase the depth of your personality. Arm yourself with a wide range of knowledge. Don't allow yourself to be stereotyped ie. not allow them to understand or get a handle on you. Bullies get scared of you then.
ReplyDelete... but then making friends becomes somewhat of a bitch too though. Only the most persistent of true friends see it through to the real you.
Best to remember never to be alone if you are being threatened by bullies. God knows what can happen if you are alone.
ReplyDeleteWell... it's all relative. If you're alone when you face the bully... it also means he's alone... and god knows what you can do to him when no one is watching...
ReplyDeleteYeahhhh...true. But if he's not alone...bye bye liao...
ReplyDeleteI find the disadvantage of being alone against a crowd is more of having no witnesses to back my account of the incident later.
ReplyDeleteThat is one good use of the mobile phone today, with its audio recorder and camera.
Yup, and call for back-up too.
ReplyDeletetrue... but that does also mean there's more area for you to hit while they are limited by only having to hit one person. I don't fear a large crowd. They only get in each other's way. I fear most the 2 or 3 person. 4 and above increases the advantage to me.
ReplyDeleteTrue...2 or 3 people will make it difficult.
ReplyDeleteall this of course based on the assumption that they are just your regular run of the mill bullies. If the 4, 5, 6, etc. persons have been training to fight in coordination, you're screwed. :P When that happens, take the punches and try and run like hell. XD
ReplyDeleteLOL...yeah. So it's best to learn how to defend oneself early on in life!
ReplyDeleteprovided...
ReplyDelete1. you're not going to become a bully yourself, coz then you'll be a Super-bully, and
2. you don't get arrogant and think that because you know some martial art you can beat any bully that comes your way, coz that's the surest way of getting beaten up. ;)
That would not be a problem if wu de is stressed during training... :)
ReplyDeleteOh you hold all the good cards here. Always keep your nose clean. It works wonders as a "get out of jail card".
ReplyDeleteWho's gonna believe that a "good" boy who's usually the butt of jokes and bullying, beat the crap out of a "tough-guy" bully who's gain notoriety picking on losers and wimps?
After all, you don't need the whole world to know... just the bully knowing he's been beaten will suffice. He won't tell. His reputation won't let him.
The audio/camera phone is not necessarily an advantage... the visciousness of an encounter can escalate if they found out about it. When you're calling a bluff, you want it done quickly. The longer you take, the weaker your position. Bullies have to be scared off (verbally or physically) within the first few moments or you're in trouble. Like snowyb's example of bullies upping the ante and digging for information on his travel paths when he unknowingly humiliated them in public by calling them out to be disciplined. ie. arms race or viscious cycle starts.
You have to know how to out-think him and use brute strength only when appropriately applied... and pick your battles. Remember dear sunzi.
I guess I am lucky I came from a All Girls school.. but there is this incident I will never forget..
ReplyDeleteI had a group of so-called close friends in Pri Two or Three, I cant remember.. anyway it was after school and we were in a mama store just next to the school. One of the girls bought a really nice rubber that comes in 4 colors in a tube.. I was kind of envied her, so she offered to lend me 70cents to buy the rubber and return her the money when I have it. Those days I only had 20cents for recess and that was only enough for a bowl of noodles. I had to walk to school which was about 20 to half an hour walk, depending how heavy was my bags.
I told this girl I dont have money to return her immediately, but she said its ok, I could take my time. So I naively took the money, so happy with the new rubber. The following day, she asked me for the money, and the next. When I couldnt pay her, she reported me to the teacher, and I was sent to the Principal's office for half a day. For a girl that age, half a day was like forever. The Principal did not even bothered to tell me I would be detained for how long, and I was like I waited forever, until my aunt came to pick me in the late afternoon. I was already tearing all over the place, in silence of course.
My aunt paid the lousy 70cents for me to the Principal, and from then on, I learnt my lesson. Never never again, I borrow. Not money, not anything. If I am given a gift, I accept it gracefully. But I dont ask or beg for it. And if I did borrow anything, I make sure I return. Some of my colleagues think I am weird, but they dont know my story, I never tell.
Now you know. ;-) Is this another form of bullying?
No, just a form of bitchiness. >.<
ReplyDeleteXD! thats worst than bullying!
ReplyDeletebut the punishment works.. though.
ReplyDeleteHehe...that girl shouldn't have offered to lend you the 70¢ in the first place. Maybe she just wanted to torment you?
ReplyDeletebtw, here's some light-hearted americanism for you... "What in the world are young primary school girls doing buying rubbers in a shop?" XP
ReplyDeletelol! rubber rubber! la!
ReplyDeleteHehe...that's a good one...
ReplyDeleterubber = condom in Americanese
kekekekeke Ok, sorry. Couldn't help it. Please... continue this most serious of discussions. :P
ReplyDeleteyeah i acted blur.. ;-P
ReplyDeletekekeke...
ReplyDelete*sigh* I have a confession. In my lower primary days, I was the bully. yeah.. pretty insecure when I was younger and had to show off to show I was stronger. But little girls don't fight, they say nasty things.
ReplyDeleteI even joined a 'gang' lol. We were the care bears group (yes, ironic, I know) And the guys had their own 'Gargamiah' group. One day, we were supposed to meet behind the school to fight. It's very much like what Jieming experienced lah. We stood in a face-off with our waterbottles. And I remembered thinking, "Now what?" But it was more exciting than scary.
Our leader and their leader started trash talking... you know, the usual 'talk' before the fight and we were poised behind her, our water-bottles on the ready. Then, she gave a war cry, and we yelled and ran towards them, swinging our weapons.... Fortunately, I grew out of that phrase when I reached upper primary.
haha cant imagine our sweet Sally a bully? well we all were, at some point of time? I was a bully to my younger siblings then.. too.
ReplyDeletetsk tsk tsk, not me. The curse of the late developer. I was usually the one picked-upon in primary school.
ReplyDeleteOne has to be circumspect in knowing when to use recording devices.
ReplyDeleteI realised from the American cartoon/comics/media that they don't seem to believe in reporting the offender, and ostracising the victim instead for doing so.
I heard some justification for it : like it's supposed to teach the victim to stand on his own 2 feet.
Well, that's crap.
If the authorities in charge, like the teachers, are not going to take responsibility, the victim either got to take it and lump it, or take steps to deal with it himself. Unwritten Rules of the Game, they say. It doesn't get a more one-sided portrayal than in the movie "Scent of a woman".
I'm not the first type, but when I take steps, it's not going to be going "by the rules".
I didn't sign up for those unwritten rules.
School rules, like the law, is a social contract that explicitly defines what is and is not acceptable conduct to your fellow schoolmates. Different people got different ideas of what is and is not acceptable, and explicit regulations is all we got.
If some blokes want to live by the "unwritten rule", it's fine by me, but don't expect me to follow it just because it's "tradition".
So if I find the "official rules" not giving me the protection I'm supposed to get, I'll make my own rules instead of following the "schoolyard rule".
And what right does anyone to complain if the counter-measures I deal out is "disproportionate" to the grievance I suffered?
yes. You can't play by the bully's rules. That's suicide. You need to change the rules but it's a balancing act though and if you're not careful, unless you intend to follow through and go all the way as in the MAD principle you have to be wary of escalation into a blood feud.
ReplyDeleteFight smart and still come out smelling like roses. Not in anger no matter how seductively tempting...
You, babe? A bully? lol
ReplyDeletewhich is why as a general rule, never judge and presume to know/understand until you get to know the real person underneath....
ReplyDeleteI wasn't a bully but then I wasn't bullied either, was tall for my age. Like Snowy, the biggest bully was probably the teachers and again in my case, it was our Chinese language teacher. Chinese language teachers are some of the worst offenders, not only do they tend to rule the classroom with an iron fist but they are very prone to favouritism. I don't really know why. Of course there were good teachers too. I think the ratio of good/bad teachers hasn't changed all that much. the difference is during my days, a teacher was allowed to hit a student.
ReplyDeleteMy biggest worry would be for some of the children from my centre, they are children with Autism. They looked normal, walk normal, and even talk normal... but as normal as you could get. They are low in their self esteem and worst, this could be easily sensed by the other atypical children or 'normal' children. They get bullied most of the time. They will find their erasers and colored pencils stolen, or broken. They are being ostracized, as well as being teased at for speaking 'funny', some of our little ones don't sound like a Singaporean child, but sometimes sound like an American child, as they pay special attention to the diction of the spoken word - especially from the TV and what other recorded words they hear. We tried to teach them to say 'No' and be assertive, but sometimes it gets backfired especially they become too assertive and are deemed as bullies instead.
ReplyDeleteIts tough to be a parent, its tough to be a teacher..and even more so being a growing-up kid.. whether normal or not. Kudos to all parents and caretakers of these children.
ReplyDelete